AIThis post was created with the assistance of artificial intelligence (AI).

When searching for the best Nintendo Mario games, players often face a choice between timeless classics and fresh experiences. The top pick, Super Mario Odyssey, stands out for its inventive gameplay and expansive worlds, making it a must-have for fans and newcomers alike. For those seeking cooperative fun, Super Mario Party Superstars offers engaging multiplayer action. Meanwhile, Super Mario Galaxy™ + Super Mario Galaxy™ 2 remains a favorite for its inventive 3D platforming. The main tradeoffs involve balancing nostalgia with innovation, as some titles lean heavily on established franchises while others push creative boundaries. Keep reading for a detailed breakdown to find your perfect Mario experience.

12
compared
4
brands
Which Nintendo Mario game should you buy?
★ Top Pick
Super Mario Galaxy™ + Super Ma
Best Overall Collection of Classic Mario Adventures
Includes two of the most acclaimed Mario games with improved visuals
See on Amazon →
Families or groups seeking engaging multiplayer platforming with helpful features
New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe
Includes multiple playable characters with unique attributes
View on Amazon →
Players who enjoy both cooperative multiplayer and fast-paced 3D platforming adventures
Super Mario 3D World + Bowser’
Includes two engaging Mario adventures in one package
View on Amazon →
RPG fans and players interested in a story-rich Mario adventure
Super Mario RPG
Vibrant graphics and colorful worlds
View on Amazon →
Fans of classic Mario games and collectors wanting a nostalgic bundle with updated visuals
Super Mario 3D All-Stars
Includes three iconic Mario games in one package
View on Amazon →
Pros & cons at a glance
Super Mario Galaxy™ + Super Ma
✓ Includes two of the most acclaimed Mario games with improved visuals
✗ Requires Nintendo Switch console, limiting access
New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe
✓ Includes multiple playable characters with unique attributes
✗ Some features may be difficult for very young players
Super Mario 3D World + Bowser’
✓ Includes two engaging Mario adventures in one package
✗ Requires Nintendo Switch console, limiting portability
Super Mario RPG
✓ Vibrant graphics and colorful worlds
✗ Lacks detailed specs and multiplayer features
Super Mario 3D All-Stars
✓ Includes three iconic Mario games in one package
✗ Limited to only three games, missing newer titles
Nintendo Game & Watch: Super M
✓ Includes multiple classic Mario titles and a digital clock
✗ Limited to pre-installed classic games, no new content
Super Mario Odyssey
✓ Vast, colorful kingdoms to explore
✗ Limited to Nintendo Switch platform
Super Mario Maker 2
✓ Extensive course creation and customization options
✗ Requires Nintendo Switch Online membership for online features
Mario Party Superstars
✓ Includes classic boards from Nintendo 64 Mario Party games
✗ No physical edition in some regions
Super Mario 3D All-Stars
✓ Includes three popular Mario games in one package
✗ No original case or manuals included
Super Mario Bros.™ Wonder
✓ Large cast of playable characters for diverse gameplay styles
✗ No detailed technical specifications available, which might concern tech-oriented players
Super Mario Odyssey
✓ Vibrant, highly detailed 3D kingdoms to explore
✗ Requires Nintendo Switch console, limiting accessibility

Complete the kit

WHOOSH! Screen Shine Go XL – Screen Cleaner Spray & Wipe...
WHOOSH! Screen Shine Go XL – Screen Cleaner Spray & Wipe…
Add to your setup →
iO CLEAN Screen Cleaner Spray (16oz - 473ml) – Best Large...
iO CLEAN Screen Cleaner Spray (16oz – 473ml) – Best Large…
Add to your setup →
EVEO Screen Cleaner Spray - Large Screen Cleaner Bottle -...
EVEO Screen Cleaner Spray – Large Screen Cleaner Bottle -…
Add to your setup →

Key Takeaways

  • The top-ranked game, Super Mario Odyssey, excels in creative worlds and innovative mechanics, appealing to a broad audience.
  • Bundle options like Super Mario Galaxy + Galaxy 2 offer excellent value for fans who want multiple classics in one package.
  • Multiplayer titles such as Super Mario Party Superstars are best suited for social gameplay and family fun.
  • Certain versions, like Super Mario 3D All-Stars, face regional differences and availability issues, affecting accessibility.
  • Price and edition variations significantly influence value, with renewed or European versions sometimes offering better deals.
2
New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe
Best for Multiplayer and Replayability
1
Super Mario Galaxy™ + Super Ma
Best Overall Collection of Classic Mario Adventures
3
Super Mario 3D World + Bowser’
Best for Varied 3D Mario Adventures

Our Top Best Nintendo Mario Games Picks

Super Mario Galaxy™ + Super Mario Galaxy™ 2Super Mario Galaxy™ + Super Mario Galaxy™ 2Best Overall Collection of Classic Mario AdventuresPlatform: Nintendo SwitchIncludes: Super Mario Galaxy™ and Super Mario Galaxy™ 2Features: Enhanced resolution, additional content, Assist Mode, free visual updateVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe – US VersionNew Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe - US VersionBest for Multiplayer and ReplayabilityPlatform: Nintendo SwitchModes: Single-player, MultiplayerCharacters: Mario, Luigi, Toadette, Nabbit, Mii charactersVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Super Mario 3D World + Bowser’s Fury – US VersionSuper Mario 3D World + Bowser's Fury - US VersionBest for Varied 3D Mario AdventuresPlatform: Nintendo SwitchGame Type: Action, AdventureMultiplayer: Local and online multiplayerVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Super Mario RPG – Nintendo Switch (US Version)Super Mario RPG - Nintendo Switch (US Version)Best for RPG Fans and Classic Adventure LoversPlatform: Nintendo SwitchGame Type: RPG, Turn-Based CombatGraphics: Vibrant, colorfulVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Super Mario 3D All-Stars (European Version)Super Mario 3D All-Stars (European Version)Best for Nostalgia and Retro CollectionPlatform: Nintendo SwitchIncludes: Super Mario 64, Super Mario Sunshine, Super Mario GalaxyGraphics: UpdatedVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Nintendo Game & Watch: Super Mario BrosNintendo Game & Watch: Super Mario BrosBest for Nostalgia and CollectorsIncludes: Super Mario Bros., The Lost Levels, Ball (Mario version), digital clockRelease Date: November 13thEdition: Golden special editionVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Super Mario Odyssey – US VersionSuper Mario Odyssey - US VersionBest for 3D Exploration and AdventurePlatform: Nintendo SwitchMultiplayer: Yes, local multiplayerIncludes Amiibo: YesVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Super Mario Maker 2 – US VersionSuper Mario Maker 2 - US VersionBest for Creativity and Custom ContentPlatform: Nintendo SwitchModes: Single Player, MultiplayerAdditional Content: Link from Zelda, new course parts, World Maker modeVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Mario Party Superstars – US VersionMario Party Superstars - US VersionBest for Party and Multiplayer FunNumber of Boards: 5Number of Minigames: 100Platform: Nintendo SwitchVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Super Mario 3D All-Stars – Nintendo Switch (Renewed)Super Mario 3D All-Stars - Nintendo Switch (Renewed)Best for Classic Compilation on the GoPlatform: Nintendo SwitchIncludes: Super Mario 64, Super Mario Sunshine, Super Mario GalaxyCondition: RenewedVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Super Mario Bros.™ Wonder – Nintendo Switch (US Version)Super Mario Bros.™ Wonder - Nintendo Switch (US Version)Best Creative Side-Scroller for New AdventuresPlatform: Nintendo SwitchGame Type: Side-Scrolling PlatformerMultiplayer: Local multiplayerVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Super Mario Odyssey – Nintendo SwitchSuper Mario Odyssey - Nintendo SwitchBest 3D Adventure for Exploration and MultiplayerPlatform: Nintendo SwitchGame Type: Action-AdventureMultiplayer: Yes, multiplayer support with Joy-Con controllersVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Specs at a glance

More Details on Our Top Picks

  1. Super Mario Galaxy™ + Super Mario Galaxy™ 2

    Super Mario Galaxy™ + Super Mario Galaxy™ 2

    Best Overall Collection of Classic Mario Adventures

    View Latest Price

    This collection stands out for offering two of the most beloved Mario games with visual improvements and extra content, making it ideal for fans seeking a comprehensive experience. Compared to Super Mario 3D All-Stars, which bundles three titles, this duo provides a more focused experience with enhanced visuals and new features like Assist Mode, which lowers the barrier for newcomers. The inclusion of new music and story content boosts replay value, though it requires a Nintendo Switch and doesn’t specify physical or digital editions. The visual enhancements make these timeless games more appealing on Switch, but some players might prefer a broader collection like Super Mario 3D All-Stars for variety. This pick suits dedicated Mario fans or collectors wanting the definitive Galaxy experience on Switch.

    Pros:
    • Includes two of the most acclaimed Mario games with improved visuals
    • Additional content and music enrich the gameplay experience
    • Assist Mode helps players with less gaming experience
    Cons:
    • Requires Nintendo Switch console, limiting access
    • No physical edition details provided, which may concern collectors

    Best for: Fans of classic Mario platformers who want an enhanced, full-length experience on Switch

    Not ideal for: Players looking for a variety of titles or a more modern 3D Mario experience like Odyssey

    • Platform:Nintendo Switch
    • Includes:Super Mario Galaxy™ and Super Mario Galaxy™ 2
    • Features:Enhanced resolution, additional content, Assist Mode, free visual update
    Our verdict
    “This collection is perfect for fans wanting the best of Galaxy in an upgraded format, but less ideal for those seeking variety or physical copies.”
  2. New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe – US Version

    New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe - US Version

    Best for Multiplayer and Replayability

    View Latest Price

    This version excels for players who enjoy multiplayer platforming with a variety of characters, offering a different experience from the 3D-focused Super Mario 3D World + Bowser’s Fury. While Super Mario 3D World caters to those who prefer colorful, cooperative adventures, New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe emphasizes traditional 2D side-scrolling gameplay with added replay value through multiple characters like Toadette and Nabbit, who provide assistance. The game’s multiplayer mode makes it ideal for families and groups, but it might be too challenging for very young or inexperienced players, and some features could require updates. If you prioritize character variety and multiplayer fun, this pick makes the most sense, though it might lack the depth of the 3D platformers.

    Pros:
    • Includes multiple playable characters with unique attributes
    • Offers diverse game modes for extended replay
    • Supports multiplayer with engaging character interactions
    Cons:
    • Some features may be difficult for very young players
    • Additional content might require updates or downloads

    Best for: Families or groups seeking engaging multiplayer platforming with helpful features

    Not ideal for: Players looking for a modern 3D Mario adventure or solo-focused gameplay

    • Platform:Nintendo Switch
    • Modes:Single-player, Multiplayer
    • Characters:Mario, Luigi, Toadette, Nabbit, Mii characters
    • Features:Help features, additional game modes
    Our verdict
    “Ideal for multiplayer fun and character variety, but less suitable for those wanting a modern 3D experience or solo play.”
  3. Super Mario 3D World + Bowser’s Fury – US Version

    Super Mario 3D World + Bowser's Fury - US Version

    Best for Varied 3D Mario Adventures

    View Latest Price

    This package combines two distinct Mario experiences, making it stand out for players who want both cooperative and solo adventures. Compared to Super Mario Odyssey, which emphasizes open-world exploration, Super Mario 3D World + Bowser’s Fury offers a more structured, colorful platforming experience with faster-paced gameplay. The addition of Bowser’s Fury introduces a new mode that expands replay options, though it might feel repetitive to some after extended play. Suitable for players who enjoy cooperative multiplayer, this title is less ideal for those seeking the open-ended freedom of Odyssey or a purely traditional platformer. Its vibrant worlds and multiplayer support make it a versatile choice, but some may find the gameplay less diverse over time.

    Pros:
    • Includes two engaging Mario adventures in one package
    • Supports local and online multiplayer modes
    • Enhanced speed and new content keep gameplay fresh
    Cons:
    • Requires Nintendo Switch console, limiting portability
    • May feel repetitive for players after long sessions

    Best for: Players who enjoy both cooperative multiplayer and fast-paced 3D platforming adventures

    Not ideal for: Solo players preferring open-world exploration or those seeking a less varied experience

    • Platform:Nintendo Switch
    • Game Type:Action, Adventure
    • Multiplayer:Local and online multiplayer
    • Features:Improved speed, new Bowser’s Fury mode, colorful courses
    Our verdict
    “Best suited for fans who want a mix of cooperative and solo 3D Mario gameplay with multiplayer support, but less ideal for those craving variety beyond platforming.”
  4. Super Mario RPG – Nintendo Switch (US Version)

    Super Mario RPG - Nintendo Switch (US Version)

    Best for RPG Fans and Classic Adventure Lovers

    View Latest Price

    This RPG offers a different flavor of Mario gameplay, appealing to players who enjoy turn-based battles and exploration. Compared to the platform-centric Super Mario 3D World or Super Mario Galaxy, this title emphasizes storytelling and strategic combat, making it ideal for RPG enthusiasts or those seeking a more leisurely pace. Its vibrant graphics and whimsical environments bring the classic Mario universe to life in a new way, although specific technical details are limited, and multiplayer isn’t a focus here. This game suits players who appreciate depth in gameplay and narrative, but those expecting a traditional platformer might find it less engaging. It’s a standout for fans wanting a nostalgic yet fresh Mario experience in an RPG format.

    Pros:
    • Vibrant graphics and colorful worlds
    • Engaging turn-based combat system
    • Appeals to fans of Mario and RPG genres
    Cons:
    • Lacks detailed specs and multiplayer features
    • Platform exclusive limits accessibility for some players

    Best for: RPG fans and players interested in a story-rich Mario adventure

    Not ideal for: Players wanting a fast-paced platformer or multiplayer experiences

    • Platform:Nintendo Switch
    • Game Type:RPG, Turn-Based Combat
    • Graphics:Vibrant, colorful
    • Multiplayer:Not specified
    Our verdict
    “A must-have for RPG lovers and those wanting a different Mario experience, but less suitable for traditional platformers or multiplayer enthusiasts.”
  5. Super Mario 3D All-Stars (European Version)

    Super Mario 3D All-Stars (European Version)

    Best for Nostalgia and Retro Collection

    View Latest Price

    This collection is perfect for fans of the original Mario titles seeking a nostalgic experience with visual updates. It bundles three classics—Super Mario 64, Super Mario Sunshine, and Super Mario Galaxy—making it a comprehensive retro package. Compared to newer titles like Super Mario Odyssey or Super Mario 3D World, it offers a chance to relive the past with modern graphics, but the limited game selection may feel restrictive for players wanting more recent innovations. Additionally, being the European version, regional restrictions could pose access issues for some. This collection suits players craving a nostalgic trip through Mario’s history, though it falls short for those wanting the latest gameplay experiences.

    Pros:
    • Includes three iconic Mario games in one package
    • Updated graphics enhance nostalgia
    • Accessible for fans of all ages
    Cons:
    • Limited to only three games, missing newer titles
    • European version may have regional restrictions

    Best for: Fans of classic Mario games and collectors wanting a nostalgic bundle with updated visuals

    Not ideal for: Players seeking newer gameplay mechanics or titles released after 2020

    • Platform:Nintendo Switch
    • Includes:Super Mario 64, Super Mario Sunshine, Super Mario Galaxy
    • Graphics:Updated
    • Region:Europe
    Our verdict
    “Ideal for nostalgic fans and collectors who want a compact, updated Mario history, but less suited for players craving current titles or broader selections.”
  6. Nintendo Game & Watch: Super Mario Bros

    Nintendo Game & Watch: Super Mario Bros

    Best for Nostalgia and Collectors

    View Latest Price

    This special edition Game & Watch stands out for celebrating the 35th anniversary of Super Mario Bros., combining nostalgia with portability. Unlike modern Mario titles, it offers a limited selection of pre-installed classic games, including the original Super Mario Bros. and The Lost Levels, along with a Mario-themed Ball game and a digital clock. Its primary appeal is to fans craving a retro experience in a compact form, but it falls short for those seeking contemporary gameplay or connectivity features. Compared with the more interactive Super Mario Odyssey, this device emphasizes nostalgia over innovation, which means it’s less suited for players wanting new adventures or multiplayer options. Still, its design and curated classics make it a charming collector’s item.

    Pros:
    • Includes multiple classic Mario titles and a digital clock
    • Nostalgic design celebrating Super Mario Bros. history
    • Portable handheld gaming device
    Cons:
    • Limited to pre-installed classic games, no new content
    • No modern features or online connectivity
    • Primarily appeals to collectors and retro fans

    Best for: Fans of retro gaming and collectors who want a portable piece of Mario history

    Not ideal for: Players looking for modern, feature-rich Mario games or multiplayer experiences on the go

    • Includes:Super Mario Bros., The Lost Levels, Ball (Mario version), digital clock
    • Release Date:November 13th
    • Edition:Golden special edition
    Our verdict
    “This device is perfect for nostalgic fans and collectors but not for those seeking new or connected gaming experiences.”
  7. Super Mario Odyssey – US Version

    Super Mario Odyssey - US Version

    Best for 3D Exploration and Adventure

    View Latest Price

    Super Mario Odyssey makes the most of the Nintendo Switch’s capabilities with its vibrant, open-world kingdoms and inventive gameplay utilizing Cappy. Compared to Super Mario Maker 2, which emphasizes creativity and course design, Odyssey offers a more polished, narrative-driven experience with diverse locales like New Donk City. Its vast worlds and new moves make it ideal for players seeking a rich, exploration-focused platformer, though it’s limited to Nintendo Switch and requires Joy-Con controllers for multiplayer. The game shines in its variety and charm, but those wanting to create their own levels or share custom content will prefer Mario Maker 2, which excels in user-generated content. Odyssey is best suited to players craving a complete, adventure-focused Mario experience.

    Pros:
    • Vast, colorful kingdoms to explore
    • Innovative gameplay with Cappy’s new moves
    • Supports multiplayer with Joy-Con controllers
    Cons:
    • Limited to Nintendo Switch platform
    • Requires Joy-Con controllers for multiplayer
    • No level creation or sharing features

    Best for: Switch owners wanting a colorful, story-driven Mario adventure with multiplayer support

    Not ideal for: Players primarily interested in game creation or online multiplayer on a broader platform

    • Platform:Nintendo Switch
    • Multiplayer:Yes, local multiplayer
    • Includes Amiibo:Yes
    Our verdict
    “Super Mario Odyssey is ideal for players seeking a lively, exploration-focused adventure on Switch with multiplayer options.”
  8. Super Mario Maker 2 – US Version

    Super Mario Maker 2 - US Version

    Best for Creativity and Custom Content

    View Latest Price

    Super Mario Maker 2 stands out for its extensive course creation tools and online sharing capabilities, surpassing the more straightforward gameplay of Super Mario Odyssey. While Odyssey offers a rich adventure, Maker 2 empowers players to craft their own levels, which can be shared globally and played by others. Its toolbox includes new course parts, characters, and the innovative World Maker mode, but mastering these tools can be complex for newcomers. The game’s reliance on Nintendo Switch Online for online features might also limit casual players. If you want endless creative possibilities and community sharing, Maker 2 offers more depth, but if you prefer curated adventures, Odyssey may be a better pick.

    Pros:
    • Extensive course creation and customization options
    • Supports online sharing and multiplayer
    • Regular free updates with new content and modes
    Cons:
    • Requires Nintendo Switch Online membership for online features
    • Steep learning curve for new players
    • Can be overwhelming for casual players

    Best for: Players interested in designing their own levels and engaging with a community of creators

    Not ideal for: Casual gamers who prefer pre-made content and straightforward gameplay

    • Platform:Nintendo Switch
    • Modes:Single Player, Multiplayer
    • Additional Content:Link from Zelda, new course parts, World Maker mode
    Our verdict
    “Super Mario Maker 2 is perfect for creative players eager to design, share, and explore endless Mario courses.”
  9. Mario Party Superstars – US Version

    Mario Party Superstars - US Version

    Best for Party and Multiplayer Fun

    View Latest Price

    Mario Party Superstars combines the best of the series with five classic boards from Nintendo 64 and a selection of 100 minigames. It offers a nostalgic trip for fans of the original Mario Party games, contrasting with Super Mario 3D All-Stars, which is more focused on single-player experiences. The game shines in multiplayer, supporting online play and save progress, making it ideal for group gatherings. However, it lacks a physical edition for some regions and doesn’t introduce many new modes, relying instead on classic content. For those seeking a lively, multiplayer party game with a mix of old and new, Superstars delivers, but players looking for more innovation might prefer other titles like Odyssey or Maker 2.

    Pros:
    • Includes classic boards from Nintendo 64 Mario Party games
    • Large selection of minigames for varied gameplay
    • Supports online multiplayer and save progress
    Cons:
    • No physical edition in some regions
    • Limited new content beyond classic modes
    • Lacks innovative new gameplay features

    Best for: Families and friends wanting a fun, multiplayer party game on Switch

    Not ideal for: Solo players or those seeking a new Mario adventure or level creation tools

    • Number of Boards:5
    • Number of Minigames:100
    • Platform:Nintendo Switch
    • Online Multiplayer:Yes
    • Controller Compatibility:Joy-Con, Joy-Con Grip, Pro Controller, Switch Lite
    Our verdict
    “Mario Party Superstars is ideal for groups seeking a nostalgic, multiplayer party experience on Switch.”
  10. Super Mario 3D All-Stars – Nintendo Switch (Renewed)

    Super Mario 3D All-Stars - Nintendo Switch (Renewed)

    Best for Classic Compilation on the Go

    View Latest Price

    This bundle offers three of the most beloved Mario titles—Super Mario 64, Sunshine, and Galaxy—in one package, making it a strong choice for fans wanting a portable collection. Unlike Super Mario Odyssey, which offers new worlds and mechanics, this set focuses on revisiting classic adventures with modern controls and features like motion controls and co-op options. The inclusion of multiple titles makes it more versatile than buying separate remasters, but the absence of physical packaging and the fact that it’s a renewed product might raise concerns about condition and completeness. For nostalgic players eager to experience these iconic games on Switch, this collection provides a convenient, portable way to do so, but it lacks the polish and new content of recent titles.

    Pros:
    • Includes three popular Mario games in one package
    • Portable gameplay on Nintendo Switch
    • Features motion controls and co-op modes
    Cons:
    • No original case or manuals included
    • Game cartridge only, no physical packaging
    • Renewed product may have cosmetic imperfections

    Best for: Fans who want to relive classic Mario adventures on Nintendo Switch in a portable format

    Not ideal for: Players seeking the latest Mario gameplay or physical new releases

    • Platform:Nintendo Switch
    • Includes:Super Mario 64, Super Mario Sunshine, Super Mario Galaxy
    • Condition:Renewed
    • Features:Motion controls, two-player Co-Star mode
    Our verdict
    “This collection is perfect for fans wanting portable access to classic Mario titles, provided they accept its renewed condition and limited packaging.”
  11. Super Mario Bros.™ Wonder – Nintendo Switch (US Version)

    Super Mario Bros.™ Wonder - Nintendo Switch (US Version)

    Best Creative Side-Scroller for New Adventures

    View Latest Price

    Super Mario Bros.™ Wonder stands out as the most innovative entry in the classic side-scrolling series, introducing Wonder Flowers that unlock game-changing effects, which adds a fresh layer of strategy compared to traditional Mario titles like Super Mario 3D World. Its large cast of playable characters and vibrant, colorful graphics make it accessible and engaging, especially for players who enjoy experimenting with different characters and power-ups. However, the game’s lack of detailed technical specs and its difficulty curve may pose challenges for newcomers. Compared to other recent Mario platformers, this title emphasizes creative effects and varied gameplay, trading off some accessibility for innovation. This pick makes the most sense for players seeking a lively, inventive side-scrolling experience with a strong cast and new mechanics, but it might be less ideal for those who prefer straightforward gameplay or are new to gaming.

    Pros:
    • Large cast of playable characters for diverse gameplay styles
    • Innovative power-ups and game effects that keep gameplay fresh
    • Colorful, engaging graphics that appeal to all ages
    • Adds new mechanics like Wonder Flowers for strategic depth
    Cons:
    • No detailed technical specifications available, which might concern tech-oriented players
    • Potentially steep difficulty for new or casual players
    • Lack of online multiplayer or co-op modes

    Best for: Players who love inventive side-scrolling adventures with a variety of characters and creative effects

    Not ideal for: Beginners or players who prefer more straightforward, less challenging platformers

    • Platform:Nintendo Switch
    • Game Type:Side-Scrolling Platformer
    • Multiplayer:Local multiplayer
    • Character Variety:Multiple playable characters
    • Power-Ups:New and classic power-ups including Elephant Fruit
    • Graphics:Colorful, cartoon-style visuals
    Our verdict
    “This game is perfect for players who want a creative, vibrant side-scrolling adventure with lots of variety and new mechanics.”
  12. Super Mario Odyssey – Nintendo Switch

    Super Mario Odyssey - Nintendo Switch

    Best 3D Adventure for Exploration and Multiplayer

    View Latest Price

    Super Mario Odyssey offers a sprawling 3D exploration experience that surpasses the more contained levels of Super Mario 3D World. Its vibrant, detailed kingdoms provide countless secrets, made even more engaging by Cappy’s capture mechanic, which introduces innovative puzzle-solving and combat options. The game’s support for multiplayer with Joy-Con controllers broadens its appeal, especially for casual gaming sessions, and the inclusion of amiibo figures adds extra content and replayability. However, the game requires a Nintendo Switch console, and its complexity can be daunting for players unfamiliar with open-world exploration. Compared to Super Mario Bros.™ Wonder, it offers greater freedom and depth, but this comes with a steeper learning curve. This game is ideal for players who enjoy expansive worlds and multiplayer fun, but those seeking a quick, straightforward platformer should consider other options.

    Pros:
    • Vibrant, highly detailed 3D kingdoms to explore
    • Innovative capture mechanic with Cappy that adds puzzle and combat depth
    • Supports multiplayer gameplay with Joy-Con controllers
    • Includes additional content via amiibo figures for added replay value
    Cons:
    • Requires Nintendo Switch console, limiting accessibility
    • Some players may find the open-world design overwhelming or challenging
    • Higher difficulty for those unfamiliar with exploration-based games

    Best for: Fans of expansive 3D worlds and multiplayer Mario adventures

    Not ideal for: Players with limited Switch access or those preferring linear, less complex gameplay

    • Platform:Nintendo Switch
    • Game Type:Action-Adventure
    • Multiplayer:Yes, multiplayer support with Joy-Con controllers
    • Includes Amiibo:Yes, Mario, Princess Peach, and Bowser wedding outfits
    • Graphics:Vibrant, highly detailed 3D environments
    • Game Length:Variable, highly expansive
    Our verdict
    “This game is perfect for players who love exploration, innovative mechanics, and multiplayer fun in expansive worlds.”
best Nintendo Mario games
What makes a great Nintendo Mario game
1
Gameplay Style and Experience
Mario games span a variety of gameplay styles, from traditional side-scrolling adventures to expansive 3D worlds and party games.
2
Platform Compatibility and Accessibility
Not all Mario games are available on every Nintendo console, which can influence your purchase options.
3
Multiplayer and Social Features
If multiplayer fun is a priority, focus on titles that excel in co-op or competitive modes.
4
Replayability and Content Longevity
Some Mario games offer endless replayability through varied levels, collectibles, or user-generated content, such as Super Mario M
How to choose your Nintendo Mario game
1
How we picked
Our evaluation focused on gameplay innovation, replayability, accessibility, and overall appeal to different player type
2
Gameplay Style and Experience
Mario games span a variety of gameplay styles, from traditional side-scrolling adventures to expansive 3D worlds and par
3
Platform Compatibility and Accessibility
Not all Mario games are available on every Nintendo console, which can influence your purchase options.
4
Multiplayer and Social Features
If multiplayer fun is a priority, focus on titles that excel in co-op or competitive modes.
5
Replayability and Content Longevity
Some Mario games offer endless replayability through varied levels, collectibles, or user-generated content, such as Sup
Vetted Nintendo Mario games ·
The best Nintendo Mario games, compared
★ Winner Super Mario Galaxy™ + Super Ma
Best Overall Collection of Classic Mario Adventures
12compared

How We Picked

Our evaluation focused on gameplay innovation, replayability, accessibility, and overall appeal to different player types. We considered critical factors such as game design quality, multiplayer options, and value for money, especially in bundles or special editions. Titles that balance classic Mario charm with new mechanics scored higher, while regional differences and platform compatibility also played a role. We ranked games based on their ability to deliver engaging experiences for newcomers and longtime fans alike, prioritizing titles that stand out for their originality and fun factor.
Everyday → specialist
Everyday & valuePremium & specialist
Which Nintendo Mario game fits you?
The everyday user
All-round, reliable
The enthusiast
Premium & high-performance
The gift-giver
Looks & craftsmanship

Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Nintendo Mario Games

Choosing the best Nintendo Mario game depends on what you value most in your gaming experience. Whether you’re after single-player adventures, multiplayer fun, or a mix of both, understanding key factors can help you select the right title. Consider the platform, gameplay style, replay value, and your familiarity with Mario games to find the best fit. Being aware of common pitfalls, like regional restrictions or price fluctuations, can also save you time and money. Here are some critical factors to weigh when making your decision.

Gameplay Style and Experience

Mario games span a variety of gameplay styles, from traditional side-scrolling adventures to expansive 3D worlds and party games. Consider whether you prefer classic platforming, puzzle elements, or multiplayer chaos. Some titles, like Super Mario Odyssey, introduce innovative mechanics that redefine the series, while others, like New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe, stick to familiar gameplay for a more traditional experience. Your choice should reflect your preferred gaming pace and complexity, ensuring sustained enjoyment.

Platform Compatibility and Accessibility

Not all Mario games are available on every Nintendo console, which can influence your purchase options. Be aware of regional variations, such as the European version of Super Mario 3D All-Stars, which might differ from the US release in content or availability. Additionally, some titles are optimized for specific consoles, like Nintendo Switch, while others may be enhanced or renewed editions. Ensuring compatibility with your existing hardware avoids frustration and guarantees a smooth gaming experience.

Multiplayer and Social Features

If multiplayer fun is a priority, focus on titles that excel in co-op or competitive modes. Super Mario Party Superstars offers a variety of mini-games perfect for friends and family, while Mario Party titles emphasize social interaction. Single-player titles, such as Super Mario Odyssey or Galaxy, are ideal for solo adventures but may lack multiplayer options. Balancing your gaming preferences with available features helps you pick titles that match your social gaming style.

Value and Editions

Price differences often come down to editions, bundles, or regional releases. For instance, a renewed Super Mario 3D All-Stars might be more affordable but could have limited availability. Bundles like Super Mario Galaxy + Galaxy 2 provide excellent value for collectors or fans wanting multiple classics. Always compare what’s included and consider regional or physical edition differences to maximize your investment and get the most gaming for your money.

Replayability and Content Longevity

Some Mario games offer endless replayability through varied levels, collectibles, or user-generated content, such as Super Mario Maker 2. Others might be more narrative-driven or shorter experiences, like Super Mario RPG. Think about how much time you want to dedicate and whether you prefer games that reward repeated playthroughs or those with a more straightforward story. High replay value can significantly enhance your overall satisfaction and justify a higher price point.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which Mario game is best for newcomers?

Super Mario Odyssey is widely regarded as an excellent starting point for newcomers thanks to its accessible controls, inventive worlds, and engaging gameplay. Its open-ended approach allows players to explore freely without feeling overwhelmed, making it welcoming for first-time players. Plus, the game’s vibrant visuals and intuitive mechanics help new players grasp Mario’s core charm quickly, setting a strong foundation for exploring other entries.

Are there Mario games that support multiplayer multiplayer gameplay?

Yes, titles like Super Mario Party Superstars and Mario Party series are designed specifically for multiplayer fun, offering a variety of mini-games and party modes suitable for friends and family. These games emphasize social interaction and cooperative or competitive play, making them ideal for group settings. If multiplayer is your priority, focusing on these titles will provide the most engaging and varied social experiences.

Should I buy a physical or digital version of a Mario game?

Choosing between physical and digital editions depends on your storage preferences and how you value ownership. Physical copies often come with collectible boxes and can be resold later, while digital versions offer immediate access and convenience. Keep in mind that regional differences or special editions might be exclusive to physical copies, and digital downloads may sometimes be limited by regional restrictions or availability. Consider your gaming habits and collection goals before making your choice.

Is it worth buying a bundle like Super Mario Galaxy + Galaxy 2?

Bundles like Super Mario Galaxy + Galaxy 2 typically provide great value by offering multiple acclaimed titles at a lower combined price. These collections are especially appealing to fans who want to experience the series’ evolution or revisit beloved classics. However, check the regional availability and whether the bundle includes all desired features, as some editions might be limited or region-specific. Overall, if you enjoy platforming games and want variety, bundles often deliver excellent entertainment and savings.

How do regional differences impact my choice of Mario games?

Regional variations can influence game content, availability, and pricing. For example, certain editions might be exclusive to Europe or North America, with differences in packaging, added content, or digital access. Regional restrictions may also affect whether you can download or access specific titles, especially in digital formats. It’s important to verify the regional compatibility of the game with your console and consider regional pricing to avoid surprises or limitations after purchase.

You May Also Like

15 Best Budget Phones Under $200 That Offer Great Value for Your Money

Here’s a meta description: “Here’s how budget phones under $200 can deliver impressive features—discover the top picks and find out which one suits your needs best.

15 Best 4K HDR Smart TVs in 2026

Discover the best 4K HDR smart TVs of 2026, including top picks for value, premium features, and beginner-friendly options. Make an informed choice today.

12 Best Nintendo Switch Consoles in 2026

Discover the top Nintendo Switch consoles of 2026. Our guide highlights the best options for every type of gamer, from premium to budget-friendly picks.

10 Best Non-Toxic Crib Mattresses for Infants That Are Safe and Comfortable

Just discover the top non-toxic crib mattresses for infants that prioritize safety and comfort, ensuring your baby sleeps soundly and peacefully.